debtor both to the Greeks and to the Barbarians.’ (116) And Pope in making Dulness the goddess of the unconscious is contrasting her with Minerva, goddess of alert intellect and wit. It is not Minerva but her obverse complement, the owl, that the printed book has conferred on Western man. “However ill-fitting their heroic garb,” Williams remarks (p. 59), “one at last finds the dunces invested with uncivilizing powers of epic proportions.” Supported by the Gutenberg technology, the power of the dunces to shape and befog the human intellect is unlimited. Pope’s efforts to clarify this basic point have been in vain. His intense concern with the pattern of action in his armed horde of nobodies has been mistaken for personal spite. Pope was entirely concerned with the formalistic pattern and penetrative